2012 Logo   Website for Beginning Linux Users

  Main Menu
Linux Help
Favorite Links
Our Community

  Site Search

Full text search of all of our exclusive web site articles.

Enter your search words:

  Linux Tips

  • Installation Help & Tips
  • Server Configuration Guide
  • For Guru Wanna-bees
  • Commands for Server Use

  •   And many more tips Here.      
      Here is what we wanted to test against:
    • Stability (days) - length of days before required reboot or human intervention
    • Performance (seconds) - speed of the OS load time from moment of system turn on to ability to start an application
    • Efficiency (seconds) - speed of commonly used applications, in this case an empty spreadsheet and new word processing file
    • Price ($s) - how much it cost to upgrade or purchase the particular OS in use
    • Pain (minutes) - how much effort in time it took to configure the system the first time

    Here is how the two systems faired after we ran them for 90 days.  We should point out that the Linux server was still solid and stable and could have run far beyond the 90 day test period.  Now mind you, we were not lab technicians.  We just wanted to see how two different Operating Systems would live side by side for 90 days.  We were shocked what a difference there was.

    Over time, Microsoft® Operating Systems (at least the WindowsXP® tested) utterly failed most of the tests.  Our results are listed below.  Again, these are just the basic stats from our personal tests and we do not publish these as some form of official challenge to anyone.

    In a particularly overt demonstration of Linux strength, the stat that stands out is in Stability.  This stat was measured in the number of days the machines operated consistantly and effectively without requiring a reboot or system restart.  Older Windows versions would have shown the blue screen of death (sudden occurance of fatal exception errors which forced us to reboot the machine), sadly even on the new Windows machine far too frequently we still in every instance had stability issues, and we had to reboot the Windows machine every 3 days due to serious instability.  We never rebooted the Linux system.

    A real suprise stat to us was the Pain statistic, which indicated in number of minutes how long it took to fully install the OS onto the machine and then get it running.  The installation procedure took longer for Windows than for Linux.  This was a shock, but validated the significant progress Linux releases have made to simplify installation.

    The only stat that  was not effected by the 90 day duration was the Price, since that was a one time instance and thereby a constant.  Linux won hands down, especially considering that SUN's OpenOffice for Linux is available for free.  This must be compared to a Windows system and the price of MSOffice®.  There are a lot of $s saved in Linux's favor here.

    Finally, we  put to bed the challenge that Microsoft runs business related software better.  In fact, the OpenOffice® suite (very similar to Microsoft Office® ) performed better in all aspects including less bugs.  On the WindowsXP® machine both Word and PowerPoint had a number of bugs with printing, displaying wysiwyg text, and in the case of Word, unexplainable sudden termination of the program.

    Without a question, in our simple real word test, we watched with our own eyes the benefits of running Linux over a Microsoft® Operating System.  The same hardware, with very different results after 90 days of use.

    This article and the Top 5 test is based on computer consultant opinions and not a conclusive test.  For a realistic evaluation refer to more than one source and judge for yourself.
    We make no claims to the validity of this article.

    Linux Defeats Microsoft Windows in Top 5

    In our top 5 user focused category tests, the RedHat Linux server wins by a far margin over the exact same configured WindowsXP system.  Linux very easily triumphed in the stability, price, and least pain categories.
    The test was simply intended to close a debate that had begun in the lunch room at our favorite IT company.  Troy and I had talked about the top five things end users want from their operating system and which OS would be best suited.  Almost everyone wants stability, performance, efficiency, good price, and as little pain as possible in their system.

    All of a sudden it dawned on us.  Back at the office we had recently installed WindowsXP® and a RedHat® Linux® server side by side.  They were both installed on the exact same hardware, dated Hewlett Packard computers.  They were mirror systems with absolutely nothing except the OS and applications software distinct.

    Troy and I went back and wrote up a plan to test these two machines side by side.

    For personal help or answers to questions, please visit our message boards.

    html 4145
    Copyright 2004 Mark Rais   All Rights Reserved.

    Linux is a registered trademark of Linus Torvalds.
    All other trademarks
    and registered trademarks on this entire web site are owned by their respective companies.
    This site is not related or affiliated with any other sites.